Register or Login

Support

Ask your question

Search

Visual Collection

Popular Questions

Most active users

  • Thai sean 992 posts | member since Nov 11, 2007
  • thedoc 1305 posts | member since Sep 10, 2006
  • jangabad 16 posts | member since Apr 25, 2010
  • April 847 posts | member since Apr 14, 2008
  • skeenan 21 posts | member since Jan 26, 2010

Films

Question

3 responses | 0 votes

Nov 26, 2009 7:30:56 PM cite

Could we create a new country that would work under the principles of socialism, that would only consist of people supporting those principles? As an experiment to really see if communism could actually work as it was meant to work.

by Fossa

Please login to rate.

Jan 28, 2010 8:05:35 PM cite

Communism can only be referenced by how it was enacted in reality. Other than 'communism in practice' there is no single concrete object that is communism. Marx and engles wrote and philosophized generalities about communism and socialism as did mao, stalin, lenin, pol pot, castro ect. Aside from marx and engels the afformetioned figures each enacted some form of communsim that they contrived from the ambiguos and maleable writings of people like marx. So to reference communism as you have in your question shows a misunderstanding, for there is no objectivef communism. In fact expiriments have been made throghout history to "really see if communsim could work" but the writings and concepts are to general and unspecific and disaster has only resulted from these expiriments. I think you should read into writngs on libertarian socialsim or anarcho- syndalicism for they both are systems which have been written extensively on in more contemporary times and they are concepts of a brand of socialism that conceptualize the elimination of the state and very strong democratic priciples.

by skeenan

Related themes
Planned economy,
Future,
Communism
Please login to rate.

Nov 27, 2009 4:03:15 AM cite

Any system of government doesen't work because the problem of man. Untill man gets his act together we will be in dire straits, and should we get our act together we wouldent need governing, each person would govern thier own actions.

by Thai sean

Please login to rate.

Nov 27, 2009 12:04:29 AM cite

It's a very interesting topic. To live under those principles, we have to attain a greater level of conscience. We need to be less egoists and become more altruists, just for the sake of the others, building a society were you feel you belong to, and also feel responsible for the rest and sense them as if they were yourself. A society were your work is to fulfill the necessities of others as your own necessity. Do you think we are capable to do that ( even as a project) with the actual level of conscience of human beings?

by magri1128

Please login to rate.